What is the best menstrual disc? Complete comparison, reviews and buying guide (2026)

Menstrual discs are becoming increasingly popular among people looking for a comfortable, discreet and more sustainable menstrual product. However, with the growing number of models available, it can be difficult to know which menstrual disc to choose. Between reusable models, disposable versions and brands such as Flex Disc, Femdisc, Nixit, Hello Disc, Lumma Disc, Saalt Disc, Selenacare Disc and Felicup, each manufacturer highlights different features. People also look for reviews to find out which product offers the best comfort, which is the easiest to use and which offers the best value for money.

If you are a beginner, it is perfectly normal to have many questions. All menstrual discs work according to the same basic principle, but they do not provide exactly the same experience. The flexibility of the membrane, the firmness of the rim, capacity, size and silicone quality can all influence comfort. This is precisely why simply comparing prices is not enough. It is better to understand the differences between each model so you can choose the one that truly suits your anatomy and habits.

In this complete guide, we will compare the main brands people search for, analyse their advantages and limitations, explain the essential criteria for making the right choice and help you identify the menstrual disc best suited to your needs.

Why are there so many different menstrual discs?

Contrary to what many people think, not all menstrual discs are the same. Although they all work according to the same principle – collecting menstrual flow in the vaginal fornix rather than inside the vaginal canal like a menstrual cup – manufacturers have developed different approaches to meet different needs.

Some brands favour a very flexible rim to make insertion easier and improve comfort throughout the day. Others prefer a slightly firmer rim that can make removal easier and provide greater stability during physical activity. There are also significant differences in capacity, the presence of a tab or other removal system, silicone texture and the overall diameter of the disc.

There are also two main categories of products: reusable menstrual discs, made from medical-grade silicone and designed to last for several years, and disposable menstrual discs, intended for single use. This distinction is important because it affects not only long-term cost but also environmental impact and everyday convenience.

What criteria should be used to compare menstrual discs?

Before comparing brands, it is essential to understand which factors actually influence the quality of a menstrual disc. Many people focus only on price, even though this is often not the most important factor.

The quality of the silicone

For a reusable model, the material used is essential. The best menstrual discs are made from high-quality medical-grade silicone, a material known for its biocompatibility, flexibility and durability. High-quality silicone withstands wear better, retains its flexibility and generally provides greater comfort during use.

The flexibility of the rim

The rim is the part that keeps the disc correctly positioned behind the pubic bone. A very flexible rim can be more comfortable but may be slightly more difficult to insert for some users. Conversely, a firmer rim can sometimes make insertion easier but may be less suitable depending on your anatomy.

Capacity

Not everyone has the same menstrual flow. Some people look for a disc with a high capacity to reduce the number of times it needs to be emptied during the day, while others prefer a more compact model for maximum comfort.

Capacity is therefore an important consideration, particularly for people with heavy periods.

Everyday comfort

A good menstrual disc should quickly become unnoticeable. When positioned correctly, it should not cause pain, discomfort or excessive pressure.

Comfort depends both on the overall design and on how well the chosen disc suits your anatomy.

Ease of removal

Some brands offer features designed to make removal easier, such as a tab or a specially designed rim. Others retain a completely traditional design.

Beginners often appreciate models that are easier to handle during their first few cycles.

Reusable or disposable menstrual disc: which should you choose?

This is a very common question, and the answer mainly depends on your lifestyle.

Disposable models, such as some discs available on the market, are appealing because of their simplicity. After use, they are simply thrown away. They can be a convenient occasional option for travelling or specific situations.

However, over the long term, the cost can quickly add up. Buying disposable menstrual products every month eventually becomes significantly more expensive than purchasing a reusable model.

Reusable menstrual discs are becoming increasingly popular for several reasons. They can be used for several years with simple maintenance, considerably reduce waste and generally offer excellent value for money.

For most users looking for a sustainable menstrual product, a reusable menstrual disc is currently one of the most appealing options.

What is the best menstrual disc?

There is no single menstrual disc that is universally better than all the others. However, certain brands stand out depending on individual needs.

People regularly compare Flex Disc, Femdisc, Nixit, Hello Disc, Lumma Disc, Saalt Disc, Selenacare Disc and Felicup to identify the model offering the best balance between comfort, ease of use, material quality and price.

Each brand has its own specific features. Some focus on exceptional flexibility, others on easier removal, while others aim to provide a good balance between comfort, reliability and durability.

In the next section, we will take a closer look at each of these brands, their features, advantages and potential limitations, followed by a complete comparison table to help you choose the menstrual disc best suited to your needs.

Comparison of the main menstrual disc brands

With the growing number of models available, it is normal to hesitate before making a choice. Each manufacturer develops its own menstrual disc with specific characteristics: diameter, rim flexibility, capacity, removal system and silicone quality. Although they all serve the same purpose, the experience can vary considerably from one person to another.

This is why it is better to compare brands according to several objective criteria rather than focusing solely on price or popularity. The best menstrual disc is not necessarily the most famous one: it is the one that best suits your anatomy, menstrual flow and lifestyle.

This table provides an initial overview, but it is useful to examine the characteristics of each model in more detail.

Felicup: a swiss menstrual disc designed for everyday use

The Swiss Felicup menstrual disc is designed for people looking for a reusable menstrual product that is easy to use and comfortable for everyday wear. Made from medical-grade silicone, it combines good flexibility with effective support, helping make both insertion and extended wear more comfortable.

Its goal is to provide a sustainable solution that can accompany users throughout all their activities, whether during a day at work, a workout or a full night's sleep. Maintenance is simple, as daily cleaning and sterilisation between cycles are sufficient to keep it in good condition for several years.

Thanks to its balance of comfort, manufacturing quality and durability, it is an interesting alternative for those who want to switch to reusable menstrual products.

Nixit: a popular choice for flexibility

Nixit is one of the best-known brands in the menstrual disc market. Its main characteristic is its particularly flexible rim, which is often appreciated by people looking for greater comfort once the disc is correctly positioned.

This flexibility can require a little adjustment during the first few insertions, but many users find that it improves everyday comfort once they become accustomed to it.

Like other reusable models made from medical-grade silicone, Nixit can be used for several years with proper care.

Lumma Disc: several sizes for different anatomies

Lumma Disc takes a different approach. Rather than offering a single model, the brand provides several sizes, allowing users to choose a disc that may better suit their anatomy.

This can be an advantage for people who already know that they prefer a smaller or larger diameter.

As with all menstrual discs, however, choosing the right size is highly personal. What works perfectly for one person may be less suitable for another.

Hello Disc: designed for easier removal

Hello Disc stands out thanks to a specific design feature intended to make removing the menstrual disc easier.

Some people, particularly those trying this type of menstrual product for the first time, may feel more confident with a system that makes the disc easier to grip during removal.

This design primarily addresses the concerns of beginners who may hesitate to try a menstrual disc because they are worried about having difficulty removing it.

Saalt Disc: a premium finish

Saalt Disc is often presented as a menstrual disc with a particularly refined finish. Made from medical-grade silicone, it focuses on material quality and a clean design.

It is mainly aimed at people looking for a durable product who also place particular importance on perceived product quality.

As with other brands, however, comfort will largely depend on how well the chosen disc suits your anatomy.

Selenacare Disc: a sustainable reusable option

Selenacare Disc is one of the reusable models attracting increasing interest. Its aim is to provide a sustainable alternative to disposable menstrual products while maintaining a high level of comfort.

Made from medical-grade silicone, it can be used for several years with proper care. It is therefore an interesting option for people who want to reduce menstrual waste without sacrificing convenience.

Femdisc: a reusable menstrual disc focused on simplicity

Femdisc is a reusable menstrual disc made from medical-grade silicone. Its design focuses on simple use and comfortable wear for several hours. As with other models in this category, comfort will mainly depend on your anatomy, your preferred level of flexibility and your personal preferences. If you are looking for a sustainable menstrual product, it may be worth comparing with other models on the market.

Flex Disc: the main representative of disposable models

Unlike most of the brands included in this comparison, Flex Disc is primarily known for its disposable menstrual discs.

This type of product may suit people who want to discover how menstrual discs work without immediately investing in a reusable model, or those looking for an occasional solution while travelling.

However, when comparing costs over several years, reusable models are generally much more economical and environmentally friendly.

What criteria should you prioritise when choosing the best menstrual disc?

After comparing the main brands available on the market, one question remains: which one should you choose? In reality, there is no universal answer. The best menstrual disc is the one that suits your anatomy, menstrual flow and lifestyle. Two people using exactly the same model can have completely different experiences. This is why it is better to understand the factors that genuinely influence the comfort and effectiveness of a menstrual disc rather than relying solely on its popularity.

Where to buy a menstrual disc?

Menstrual discs can now be purchased from specialist stores, directly from manufacturers and from some pharmacies and health stores. However, availability varies between retailers, and not every model will necessarily be available in physical stores.

If you are looking for a menstrual disc in a pharmacy, the selection is generally more limited than on specialist websites. Specialist retailers often make it easier to compare different models, dimensions, capacities, levels of flexibility and other features before making a choice.

Buying from a manufacturer or specialist retailer can also provide access to more comprehensive documentation, usage advice and, in some cases, customer service that can answer questions about choosing or caring for your disc.

Wherever you purchase it, take the time to check the quality of the materials, the disc's dimensions and capacity, and the manufacturer's recommendations. Choosing a model suited to your anatomy is often more important than where you buy it.

FAQ: frequently asked questions about menstrual discs

What is the best menstrual disc?

There is no universal answer to this question. The best menstrual disc is the one that suits your anatomy, menstrual flow and preferences. Some models prioritise flexibility, while others make removal easier or offer several sizes. Comparing the characteristics of each disc can help you choose the one that best meets your needs.

Menstrual disc or menstrual cup: which should you choose?

Menstrual discs and menstrual cups are two reusable menstrual products, each with their own advantages. A cup stays in place using a gentle seal inside the vaginal canal, while a disc sits higher up behind the pubic bone without creating suction. Some people find discs more comfortable, particularly during physical activity or penetrative sex, while others prefer the simplicity of a menstrual cup.

Are menstrual discs available in pharmacies?

Yes, menstrual discs are available in some pharmacies and health stores. However, not all retailers carry the same products, and the selection is often more limited than on specialist websites. If you are looking for a specific model or want to compare several options, specialist websites generally offer more information and greater availability.

How long can a reusable menstrual disc be used?

A reusable menstrual disc made from medical-grade silicone can be used for several years when properly cared for. It is important to follow the manufacturer's recommendations regarding daily cleaning and sterilisation between cycles to preserve its quality.

Our opinion

Menstrual discs are an excellent alternative to traditional menstrual products for people looking for a comfortable, discreet and sustainable solution. While no single model will be perfect for everyone, taking the time to compare different discs according to their flexibility, capacity, dimensions and ease of use can help you make a more informed choice.

Beyond the product itself, choosing a reusable menstrual product can also be part of a broader approach to responsible consumption and sisterhood, where sharing experiences, information and mutual support helps everyone find the solution that works best for them. Whatever model you choose, the most important thing is to select a disc that suits your anatomy and lifestyle so you can experience your periods with greater comfort and peace of mind.